Validity vs. Reasonableness

While most of our applications do validity checks on data, not all of them do reasonableness checks.  Let me explain the difference.

Data Validation.  Let us suppose you have a number of fields on the screen:  name, address, birth date, phone number, and spouse's name, spouse's address, spouse's birth date, spouse's phone number and a marriage date.  Data validation would ensure that if there is a birth date, it is a valid date.  So in this case it would check to ensure that all of the date fields are valid.  It would also check to ensure that the phone number follows any one of a number of different standards, but predominantly the fact that it is numeric in nature.  You can also extend data validation to more complex tasks such as determining if the postal code is correct.   In general terms, data validation serves to ensure that a single piece of data is a valid for that data type.

Data Reasonableness.  OK, now that we've gotten the basics out of the way, there are still a number of checks that we can perform.  If there is a marriage date, then the date must be a certain time period after the birth date of both parties.  This is not just a simple "if marriageDate > spouseBirthDate then Happiness()".  We need some additional logic to ensure that even if the data is valid, it also must make sense.  Having data make sense is as important as ensuring that it is valid.

While there are many schools of thought on this, most post secondary training lumps both data validation and data reasonableness together under the "validation" banner.  This, unfortunately, has had the effect, in most cases, of putting data reasonableness checks in the background or has the checks embedded deep within the business logic of the application.  In most cases these checks can be done at the UI level, really quickly and prevent a lot of background processing that clogs the servers.  The other big problem is that some of these reasonableness checks are missed because "I thought the client was going to do that".

Just remember, there is a lot of data checking that needs to be done and reasonableness is just another item in the list.